We took all of the comments from the Moon Hunters Square Enix Collective project page and made a word cloud with them, to find out what people most cared about, for better or for worse. Some of it was semi-obvious — graphics and art, for example… but some might surprise you!
We excluded the words “game” and “really”, but everything else is there! We’re really happy with the reaction so far.
I think it’s clear that the aesthetic we’ve chosen resonates with some people but puts others off. And that’s okay! We’re not interested in making a middling game for everyone — we’re interested in making a best-game-ever for one slice of gamers. So we’ll just have to accept that our taste is different from others’.. as long as SOME people out there love what we’re doing, that’s ideal. Pixel art isn’t for everyone, but neither is poutine.
We’re still collecting all feedback, suggestions, and ideas, so do leave comments anywhere and everywhere and we’ll be sure to consider them seriously. And if you haven’t signed up for the Moon Hunters newsletter yet, make sure to do so soon, or you might miss hearing the first bit of a song being composed for the game…